The BRRRR Strategy: The Two Numbers That Decide Everything

BRRRR — Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat — is how investors recycle one pile of capital into many doors. It works exactly as well as two numbers, and no better.

All-In Cost as % of ARV: Full Cash Recovery vs Money Left in Deal: All-in cost recovers full investment 75%, All-in cost leaves money buried 85%.

Number 1: cash recovery at the refinance

You buy distressed, renovate, rent it, then refinance at the new appraised value. The bank typically lends 75% of the after-repair appraisal. Your recovered cash = that new loan minus everything you have in the deal.

The discipline: purchase + rehab + costs should sit near 75% of ARV. At that line you pull your whole investment back out ("infinite return" on the capital left in). At 85% of ARV you leave real money buried — which caps how many times you can repeat.

Number 2: post-refi cash flow

The refinance loan is bigger than your acquisition loan — and the property has to cash-flow under the new payment. This is where BRRRR quietly fails: the deal penciled at purchase, then the refi payment ate it. Underwrite the end state first: market rent minus full expense load minus the post-refi debt service. If that number is negative, you've built a treadmill, not a portfolio.

The sequence that protects you

  1. Lock ARV with real comps before you buy — not hope
  2. Bid backward from 75% of ARV minus rehab minus a contingency (renovations run over; assume yours will)
  3. Confirm the refi lender's seasoning requirements (many want 6+ months) and DSCR floor (plan on 1.20 or better) before closing, not after
  4. Stress-test the refi at +1% interest — if it only works at today's rate, it barely works

Run your numbers in the BRRRR calculator — it computes both deciding numbers at 75% LTV. Or type the address into the analyzer and get the BRRRR verdict alongside five other strategies in 30 seconds.

Now try it on the house you're actually looking at.

Paste the address. In about 30 seconds you get a straight BUY, NEGOTIATE, or PASS, the number that decided it, and the price where the deal works. The AI reads the listing; a real math engine does every calculation.

Your first 3 analyses are free. No credit card.

Check this deal free →